La Macaronicité 2: basic technique and simple macaron recipe
Mesdames et messieurs, enfants et français charmants,
So you want to make macarons? Welcome to the second instalment of La Macaronicité at Syrup & Tang! If you missed the introduction, click here to read it.
La Macaronicité: Technique and knowledge
Main sections:
Ingredients
Fundamentals
Recipe A — macarons au blanc monté
Background to my recipe
Please remember that this material is copyright. If you want to use any part of it (beyond a very short quote), please contact me for permission.
There's a lot of information here and it's possible that not everything applies to your kitchen or experience. I don't know everything about them (there's a limit to how many kilos of almond meal a poor writer can buy!). I welcome feedback about other solutions/explanations/ideas, but please don't submit comments listing other recipes unless it contributes to a better understanding of the actual process and problems. You're welcome to contact me directly if you prefer and I'll incorporate helpful info into the article where appropriate.
Ingredients
The macaron batter consists of only four ingredients:
- almond meal (ground almond) – amandes en poudre
- pure icing sugar (confectioner's sugar, no starch added) – sucre glace
- egg whites, preferably old – blancs d'œufs
- sugar, preferably caster sugar – sucre semoule
On occasion you might also see mention of cream of tartar or salt, both of which strengthen egg white foam.
The batter may be coloured (very common) and flavoured (less common, though not too difficult).
There are three types of recipe:
- macarons au blanc monté (1) – a simple eggwhite foam is combined with the dry ingredients; preferred in Pierre Hermé's books
- macarons au blanc monté (2) – a simple French meringue is combined with the dry ingredients; in most other books, including Alain Ducasse
- macarons au sucre cuit – an Italian meringue is combined with the dry ingredients; preferred in most professional books
I'll explain the second recipe type (French meringue) here, and introduce the third type in the next article.
Fundamentals
Almond meal is a fine cream-coloured powder made from ground blanched almonds. If it is very fresh it might be a little damp, so you could dry it very gently in a barely warm oven. You can make your own almond meal, but it will be hard to grind fine enough and will be damp.
Icing sugar (confectioner's sugar) is often sold with starch added (then called 'icing mixture' in Australia). This prevents it from clumping, but can leave a pasty mouthfeel if used in icing and is undesirable (though not fatal) in macarons. Use unadulterated (pure) icing sugar if possible.
The almond meal and icing sugar should be put through a high speed food processor or a (clean) blade coffee grinder to obtain a very fine powder (about 10 seconds on highest speed should suffice). Most almond meal is more like sand than flour, so if you leave it unprocessed the macarons will have a coarser surface. No big drama, but we're looking for perfection, right?
Egg whites consist of proteins and quite a lot of water. The water can make the final batter unmanageably wet, either in the making or in the oven (where the macarons refuse to dry adequately). Old egg whites have lost some of their water content through evaporation so can yield a more successful batter, though this is by no means guaranteed (from personal experience, even evaporating 15% of some egg whites didn't help). There are also changes in the composition of the proteins with time, but I haven't seen any analysis to explain why this might be better for macarons. It is also said that older egg whites yield a thicker meringue shell. Many professional recipes use dried egg white (egg white powder) to bolster the protein content.
Bottomline: do not fret about a few hours of ageing here or there; if you have time to age your eggs that's good. If you don't, then just use the oldest eggs (ie, not the newest carton) in your fridge that haven't gone rotten yet.
Oven temperature is a big problem. Very few recipes specify whether the author uses a conventional or a fan-forced (convection) oven. This difference has implications for (1) even temperature, (2) speed of temperature recovery after putting the tray in the oven, (3) actual temperature appropriate for your oven, (4) humidity.
It would seem that a fan-forced oven sometimes offers greater success (though others say the opposite), but I haven't been able to test this firsthand, as I live in renting-with-old-gas-oven land. Many recipes that explicitly mention a conventional oven recommend starting the macarons at a high temperature and then leaving the oven door ajar and dropping the temperature. There are two possible reasons: (1) this gives the initial lift that the batter needs and then permits drying and firming without burning (propping the door open helps lower the temperature quickly), and (2) this seals the surface of the macaron quickly, preventing cracking and helping it lift as the foot forms. Of course you could take the Roux brothers' (Roux Brothers on Patisserie) approach and just have two ovens at different temperatures. Yeah, right.
To ensure slow, even heat distribution underneath the macarons, it's desirable to use two or even three baking trays (cookie sheets) on top of each other. Again, many authors fail to mention that they're using (and stacking) professional-grade aluminium sheets which are considerably thicker than the cheapo homecook type. I'd probably need six of my flimsy baking trays stacked together! I recently tried using an insulated baking sheet for the first time and found that my previous problems with sticky-bottomed macarons were greatly reduced.
Baking on non-stick baking paper is the best approach. Silicone sheets and Silpat are fine for a successful batch, but just try removing tenaciously sticky, fragile, failed macaron shells from one of these and it will end in tears!
Meringue: when you incorporate it into the almond mixture, you don't want any pussyfooted folding (e.g., as for mousse or sponges) but nor are you allowed to beat the shit out of it. You need to work quickly and efficiently, incorporating the dry ingredients smoothly but without excessive mixing. At first the ingredients won't mix well, but it comes together quickly. The final batter is pale and smooth, with no visible aeration.
Piping: if you're confident at piping, pipe from the side, pulling the tail up over the macaron so that it disappears quickly. However, it's easier to pipe vertically over the centre, about 5 mm above the tray surface. Flick the nozzle towards the edge as you pull away to finish.
Crusting: more than half of the world's macaron recipes mention leaving the piped macarons to rest so that they form a 'skin' or 'crust'. There seems to be very little evidence that this makes any difference in the final product. For some batters it will actually cause a duller shell. Maybe resting is necessary for some people's kitchens, but I didn't observe a benefit across four tests. It does, however, seem wise to let the batter settle for just a few minutes on the baking tray (see 'cracking'). [UPDATE: after more testing, I now recommend permitting the shells to sit for half an hour or so. It helps reduce some problems if your oven has strong heat below the baking tray.]
Humidity: I doubt that humidity in the oven is an issue for anyone, but do avoid making macarons on a very humid day as the mixture will tend to be too damp or require adjustment.
Cracking: a few minutes after going into the oven, some macarons batters will develop fissures. In my experience this is the result of (1) overmixing, or (2) rushing the piped batter straight into the oven.
Maturing/ripening: the shells are not at their best when fresh. They will be slightly chewier around the edges than expected. Usually the macarons are assembled and then stored in the fridge for one to two days, after which they are heavenly.
For your edification, here are some useful photos:
Freshly piped good batter is on the left. Note how the overbeaten batter, on the right, is darker and looks slightly translucent. (The specks in the batter are vanilla.)
If you're not scared yet, still ready to face the batter, congratulations!
Recipe A
macarons au blanc monté (2); (French meringue)
This method is the one you'll find almost everywhere on the internet and in most cookbooks. It is simple but fraught with disappointment. In my experience (dodgy ovens, no fan, domestic trays), this style of recipe can yield less than 50% success rate. If you possess a digital probe thermometer or a sugar thermometer I'd recommend waiting for Recipe B. But there are perfectly happy people out there with, presumably, better kitchens than I. (You can see a charming fella explaining it (in French) on video here, and one of the clearest shorter explanations in writing is by Coco&Me. One brave experimenter, Veronica's Test Kitchen, may also have useful tips for you if you prefer this style of recipe.)
Regardless of what the recipes say, I suggest first deciding how many eggs you want to sacrifice. Crack and separate the eggs, remembering to keep the whites and all vessels and implements scrupulously free of fat or egg yolk. You don't need to weigh the egg whites at this point. One egg white will yield about fourteen 3-4 cm macaron shells.
This recipe will benefit most from aged egg whites or egg white powder. You can age the whites by leaving them uncovered at room temperature for 24-72 hours in a shallow bowl. This allows some of the moisture to evaporate. Cover the bowl with gauze or kitchen paper (not plastic) if you want to avoid any dust or other surprises. People are often apprehensive about leaving egg whites at room temperature, but the final cooked product will be safe even if the raw egg white might have been contaminated.
Formula and method
When you're ready to start cooking, weigh the egg whites and then scale the recipe appropriately. The formula is below.
'eggwhite' refers to the weight of the egg whites in grams. The righthand column provides an example calculation.
| Ingredient | Amount | Example (with eggwhite=50 gm ) |
| Almond meal | 1.3 x eggwhite | 1.3 x 50 = 65 gm |
| Icing sugar | 1.6 x eggwhite | 1.6 x 50 = 80 gm |
| Castor sugar | 0.8 x eggwhite | 0.8 x 50 = 40 gm |
| Egg white | 50 gm | |
| Total weight | _______ 235 gm |
A batter with 50 gm egg white should yield one baking tray 30 cm x 40 cm or approximately 25 shells.
Preheat your oven:
Conventional oven: centre rack, 180C. Convection oven: 160C
- Stack two or three heavy baking trays. Line the top tray with non-stick baking paper. If you're well organised, mark the paper with 2 or 3 cm circles, spaced about 4 cm apart (the piped batter will spread about 1 cm).
- Process the almond meal and icing sugar at high speed to achieve a fine powder. Sift (or whisk the powder by hand) to break up any lumps of powder.
- In a clean bowl, beat the room-temperature egg whites until foamy and just at soft peaks. Gradually beat in the castor sugar, adding a little at a time. Beat on medium speed for a number of minutes until you have a firm, glossy and compact meringue.
- Sprinkle half of the dry mixture over the meringue and fold in with a spatula using a circular motion around the bowl and under the batter. Repeat with the remaining powder. You don't need to be gentle, but the goal is to incorporate the dry ingredients quickly to avoid overmixing. It's better to undermix than overmix. You can add colourings or flavourings during this mixing.
- The final batter should be the colour of pale ivory (if you haven't coloured it) and smooth and thick but flowing (typically referred to as being 'like magma', but as few of us have visited an active volcano or been to the centre of the Earth…). A ribbon of batter dropped from a spoon onto the top of the remaining batter should take about 30 seconds to disappear.
- Dab a little batter under each corner of the baking paper on the tray to anchor it (otherwise it'll slip).
- Spoon the batter into a piping bag/gun with a 8-10 mm nozzle and pipe evenly onto the baking paper. Mild peaks should settle back into the batter eventually. If they don't disappear, tap the tray repeatedly on a table until the peaks have largely disappeared. Usually the batter will spread a little and any bumps will disappear. Sometimes the batter is quite runny and will rapidly flatten out. (It might be overmixed.) This consistency will often yield irregular shells. If the batter never stops spreading then you should probably scrape it all back into a bowl, gently add some more almond meal and try again.
- If you want, you can leave the piped batter to dry for anywhere between 20 mins and two hours.
- Place the tray in the oven. If you're using a conventional oven, cook as normal for two mins and then open the oven door about 2.5 cm and place a wooden spoon between the door and the jamb to permit hot air to escape for the rest of the cooking time. (Your spoon might get a bit singed, so soaking it in water briefly beforehand is a good idea.) For a convection oven, you will need to experiment a little, possibly leaving the door ajar for the whole time.
- At the 5 minute mark the shells should have lifted and developed 'feet'. At the 6-7 minute mark they should be starting to colour just slightly. Rotate the baking sheet if the colouring is uneven. The outermost shells often have to be sacrificed in order for the centre ones to be cooked, but the majority should be no more than the palest cream colour. They are probably ready if a shell moves only reluctantly on its foot when you lightly nudge it with a finger.
- Remove from the oven and leave on the tray for a minute or two. Gently try to lift one of the outermost shells. A slight twisting motion or a peeling motion can help. If the shells stick badly, but are firm, try spraying or brushing a little water under the baking paper. This will moisten the paper and soften any stuck bits after 1-2 minutes. Don't use too much water or the shells may start to dissolve around the edges. Remove each shell by gently peeling away the baking paper or with the aid of a thin palette or paring knife. Another solution to the sticking problem can be to place the paper or Silpat (with stuck macarons) in the freezer for a while.
- Once removed from the sheet, leave the shells to cool on a wire rack, face up.
- If you haven't already made a filling, do so now. A simple chocolate ganache is one of the easiest quick fillings. (Break 50 gm dark chocolate into a bowl. Bring 60 gm cream to a gentle simmer and then pour over the chocolate. Leave to stand for two minutes, then mix together with a spatula. Allow to cool slowly, stirring occasionally. When completely cool, apply a small blob to the underside of one shell and gently press another shell on top. Refrigerate for 24-48 hours if you are the patient type.)
- The plain shells can be frozen for a few weeks quite well. Complete macarons store well in the fridge for two to three days. After that they become softer. Eat macarons at room temperature.
Background to my recipe
A very standard formula for the French meringue style of macaron recipe is approximately 1.25:2.3:1.0:0.3 (almond:icing sugar:egg white:caster sugar). Variants of this are used by Alain Ducasse, Christophe Felder, J.M.Perruchon & G.J.Bellouet and Dean Brettschneider. Pierre Hermé's formula is similar, though not using a meringue. Each of these authors has a different approach to temperature and crusting. Popular American writer David Lebovitz published a chocolate macaron recipe on his site which many people found reliable (and is the one I made without trouble and showed a picture of in the first article in this series). His recipe is, however, much sweeter and uses a stronger meringue. I noticed, too, that Pascal Rigo's popular recipe also takes this approach, as does Sydney chef Justin North in his recent book French Lessons. I didn't want the sweetness, but tried adapting the approach, with the result presented above (formula of 1.30:1.60:1.00:0.80). The total sugar is only slightly higher than the most common formula and the slight increase in almond meal seems to make it less wet.
Famous internet recipes: if you go surfing you'll find many recipes. Some are useful, some are rubbish, and many are unattributed. There's a very popular online recipe which has spread far and wide but is rarely correctly attributed to Pascal Rigo (from his wonderful book American Boulangerie). The majority of the remaining recipes are from Pierre Hermé's various books.
Famous chefs' recipes: even Hermé has occasionally underdescribed his recipes, but real disapproval should be directed at those who have blithely provided poorly explained recipes for a product as temperamental as this. I greatly doubt that most restaurants make their macarons using the first style of recipe I discuss (unless they have access to egg white powder), so why foist it on the uninitiated? Note, too, that French pâtissiers readily admit that it can take some time for a macaron-maker to get used to a new kitchen if he/she changes jobs.
Troubleshooting
My macarons are delicate and sticky. They fall apart or lose their insides when I try to lift them off the baking paper. Solution: Don't wet the paper. Instead, place the sheet of paper (with stuck macarons) on a drying rack and walk away for a few hours. In my experience the shells will be fairly easy to peel off once they've cooled and their bases have dried a little. These shells will usually be too damp for use for proper macarons. Save them for one of the alternative uses listed below.
My macarons are firm and chewy. Solution: Cook them for less time or at a lower temperature.
My macarons brown too quickly on top. Solution: Try covering a spare oven shelf with foil and place it on the rung above the macarons in the oven.
My macarons have a big empty space under the shell. Solution: Cook them at a higher temperature. (There may also be other causes.)
My macarons have frilly feet which extend sideways from the shell. Solution: This is often a problem with the simple recipe, but seems worse at low temperatures. Try letting the piped batter rest for a while before baking.
Alternative uses
Whilst I wish everyone success, it's worth having a backup use for any abortive macaronic adventures.
Dessert 1: break up the macarons and place a number of pieces in a tall glass. Add morello cherries. Pour on some port. Leave to stand for 15 minutes. Top with whipped cream. Pour a little cherry juice over the cream. Serve.
Dessert 2: make a trifle-like dish with berries.
Dessert 3: give to unsuspecting friends or neighbours as 'soft almond meringues'.
Phew!
You can read La Macaronicité 1: an introduction to the macaron.
La Macaronicité 3: the more reliable macaron recipe and a few tips.
La Macaronicité 4: fillings, flavours, frippery.
La Macaronicité 5: Macawrongs and macarights, macarons day and night.
- DM
Filed under: cooking, food, hl, macarons, recipes
Similar posts (perhaps!):
You are amazing!!! Vida x
Thanks so much Vida!
Right now I feel more exhausted than anything else, I can assure you.
Duncan, I can imagine!!! If I was there I would give you a huge hug!!! You have gone into such detail that I believe I will not fail again… I may have to invest in a food processor as well as a kitchenaid (been meaning to anyway plus it is xmas) to really get there but I am willing to go all out for the famous "macaron"… The world owes you an enormous gratitude, I know I do, x x x
You certainly need something to make the almond meal finer… no coffee grinder or blender? For the meringue in this recipe, an electric handheld beater will be sufficient.
At last. This is amazing. Okay, that's my weekend sorted. Very pleased you've included the exact weights of egg whites required, which is all too often left out of these recipes where exact quantities are critical. To add another complication and twist, have you thought of making your own Almond meal. I can't remember whose recipe it was but the suggestion was that a lot of the stuff we buy is stale.
Duncan, I do have a blender so I will try with that and of course I have a handheld mixer but I thought with xmas and all it was a really genenuine excuse to purchase a Kitchenaid! Vida x
@Ed: making your own almond meal isn't advisable (see somewhere in the article above). Whilst it will taste fresh and more fragrant, the meal will be damp – and commercial almond meal is made using a different grinding process too. Unless one is willing to then dry it for a while, it just adds an additional variable (and time) to the procedure. I have noticed different flavours as a result of different almond meals, but most of the time the flavouring/filling will mask that — if I were making macarons commercially, I'd choose my almond meal carefully, but for normal home use, no.
Duncan, with your photos, I am now 100% certain that I overbeat the mixture. The batter looked too translucent and also the resulting cooked macaron looks exactly like the bad one you've shown.
I've left the macaron for a day now and actually they taste quite good as a "biscuit" as my sister stated. I have to agree, they've got a nice almond flavour and I'm getting used to the chewy texture.
However, I do want to make a perfect macaron so I'm still hanging out for your second more reliable recipe.
I found a recipe over at Kitchen Wench from Ellie. These were the macarons Ellie made. They looked great too. When I emailed her for some clarification, she said that even with this recipe, she had a quite a few failures as well and she isn't sure why. Is this similar to the next recipe you will be sharing? Hopefully you will have more tips to reduce the failures.
It's been a day of recovery and I'm ready to give macarons another try.
Oh by the way, which of the two macarons cooked at different temperatures taste better? The one at 120 deg has a better shape, but the colour of the one at 180 deg looks nicer.
Oh, hyperlinking didn't work. Here was Ellie's macaron post.
http://www.insanitytheory.net/kitchenwench/2007/05/06/melt-in-your-mouth-macarons/
Thanh, the recipe Ellie is using at Kitchen Wench is a similar principle but with a few differences from what I will write about in the next article.
Which of my macarons tasted better? Hmmm… I must say that as long as the shell is successfully, there is very little difference in flavour. The 120C version was actually prettier — it rose slightly more. One problem (depending on one's oven) is in getting the shells to cook without getting spots of browning (well, deep cream colour in this case). The nuttiness of the slight browning is nice, but not desired in this product (though one could rebel).
I'm glad you've recovered from your disappointment at the first batch!
Given that I have just inherited 5 kids for the school holidays, my macaron adventures will have to wait…
And I thought Hollandaise could smell fear….
**gulp**
Duncan…I am in awe. What a wonderful, thorough, informative and well executed post.
Can't wait for your Italian meringue post, which is my preferred technique. I think they are a little easier to make that way, as long as you're not scared of working with liquid molten sugar and have a kick arse kitchen aid or Hobart mixer
)
Frikkin' brilliant post (I don't have mellie's gift for prose). I'm inspired – and NEARLY brave enough to attempt a batch.
(nearly)
Thanks mellie/Anna/pg. The Italian meringue version is now up on the site. Don't fear if you don't have a fancy kitchen machine. You can make it with an electric handbeater too.
Hi Duncan,
these series of posts on macarons are terrific.
I just want to clear up something. At Pierre Hermé Paris, macarons are made using an Italian meringue. I think I do remember that he uses a simple egg white foam in his first cookbooks but PH10 and his lastest cookbooks are more accurate and show the real processes.
x fannt
Thanks for that helpful comment Fanny and welcome to Syrup & Tang! I'm not surprised to hear that he uses the Italian meringue in real life — I wonder if he actually was using a simple eggwhite foam at the beginning, or if the recipe in his early desserts book was an adaptation for the public? In fact, it's also a good question whether any of the professionals who have published French meringue macaron recipes ever actually make them that way — anyone with some inside gossip?
Macarons have been a very recent challenge in my baking club (although not a compulsory task based on the club's rules) and only a few of us have finally done the 'right' thing. I have done mine and have tried several more which I consider a success (as they got feet, or rather) posted on my blog. I am curious about these beauties and have become obsessed and mad about them! I am trying different versions, different colours, different flavour and I become aware they are a lot, lot, lot more to overcome out there. The possibilities are unlimited! I just love macarons. And thank you, I've finally found a site to read more about them. I'll refer your site to my baking club members, with your permission, of course. Cheers from New Zealand!
Welcome arfi! Your site looks great, but I couldn't find the macarons. I hope you have fun baking!
I've taken your email address out of your comment, just so that you don't risk any spam. Anyone can visit your site to contact you so that's probably the best way:)
[...] After a particularly sticky macaron disaster a few weeks ago I was thrilled to find this photographic guide to making macarons. H/T David [...]
hi! i love your 5-part write up on macarons (: i've been trying to make them recently.. whenever, i take out the macarons when the shells are cooked, i get soggy insides. but if i try and bake it longer to cook the inside, i get burnt shells. HELP! should i leave it longer on a cooling rack like you mentioned or should i change the temperature? also, i stay in singapore, where its very humid. does the humidity affect the way the macarons turn out? THANKS (:
hi there ,
Any idea why my macarons look like Amaretti Biscuits(no feets at all) ???
I used the Italian meringue method.
Thank's
Regards,
Jen
Thank you for a great macaron recipe – Why is it that it's so hard to find a recipe using ratios of ingredients & weight?! Thank you.
I made your recipe & the batter was perfect magma. But could anyone tell me why many of the baked cookies turned out lop-sided? – the top was askew on top of the frilly feet (the feet were too large also). Other than that problem, they are lovely.
Hi Claude. It's only really professional bakers who use ratios, and the insistence of home cooks in *a certain country* for volume measures means that weights are often given less importance.
The lop-sided problem is something I had for a long time never experienced, but I've now begun to understand it — (1) if you rest the baking sheet on an angle, you'll often get uneven macarons, (2) if you pipe too forcefully from one edge, it appears that the batter can adhere too strongly to the parchment, (3) uneven heat while cooking (either oven heat or the use of steel sheets with hotspots).
In general, a total lack of feet or very soggy insides can be the result of overmixing *or* of poor bottom heat in the oven.
Thank you for the info, Duncan. Yes, we here in the US just can't seem to understand metric volume, etc. It would make things much easier if we did!
I was also wondering if it was something to do w/my piping…I rest my pans on a level surface & I have had mostly successful batches w/these cookie sheets & ovens seem to be very even temp. The macaron look so strange – the beautiful/perfect lid actually holds it's pretty shape & slides off the rest of the dough/foot! I actually put my hand in the oven & gently nudged the tops back into place on some of them before they were finished baking – it worked. They were lovely – no headspace between lid/foot section, proper texture, etc. I will try to do whatever I did before w/my piping & see if that helps.
Your website is wonderful. I really like your holiday macaron!
first time was disaster. 2nd time was beautiful but too sweet. 3rd time ok. 4th and NOW… DISASTER. What happened??? surface is no longer smooth… and they "shrank" when i took out of the oven. there is one batch in the kitchen now… which has turned brown becoz i got fed up when i did not see the feet . GRRRRRRRRRRRR…
Ah Ha! I've figured out my macaron problem – the lopsided macawrongs! The first recipe I ever tried was a recent one published in September 2008 Gourmet magazine. They have you add SALT to the unbeaten egg whites -which is WRONG. According to McGee, you shouldn't add salt to unbeaten egg whites, it increases whipping time & decreases the foam's stability (pg 104) – you add salt w/other ingredients….Gourmet should know better than that! When I only added salt, it did take longer to whip the whites but my macaron were ok – had a bit of head space but that could be because the recipe said a 300 degree oven (too cold). When trying your recipe, to "hedge my bets" & get my whites whipped faster/stronger, I added salt & cream of tartar. There must be some chemical reaction taking place between the salt & COT because every batch made with those 2 ingredients was lopsided. And my latest 2 batches with no salt & no cream of tartar were lovely!! Citrus juice (another ingredient in the Gourmet recipe – Grapefruit juice) would probably cause a similar problem because lemon (an acid) & grapefruit(?) work like COT to control the reactive sulfur in egg whites. McGee doesn't address this particular chemical reaction in his book but something is going on. A chemist out there could probably explain?
Your recipe is really good (not sickly sweet & measured in weight not volume – much more accurate)- if only I had followed it EXACTLY & not let my "knowledge" from the previous recipe screw it up. Learn something new every day! Hope this helps other macaron bakers!
Hi Claude. I'm so glad you've had more luck:) Many recipes carry over the idea of stablising a meringue with salt/cream of tartar/acid. I can't see the point, given what is then done to the meringue. I don't necessarily think there's a problem with it… just no demonstrated need. And yes, you have to follow the recipe to the letter until you get the feel for how the batter should feel and get along with your oven. I hope you have heaps of fun making macarons now!
Just wondering if you ever came across the reason for lopsided macarons? I have tried and tired again (using italian meringue, no lemon juice, no salt, no cream of tartar, drying for 30 min, oven at 350, 325, and 300F) and every single batch is lopsided.
HI Marina. The only causes I've seen so far for lopsidedness are (1) if the tray is left to rest on an angle, (2) if the oven or oven rack is on an angle, (3) if there are hotspots on the baking tray, so that some parts of certain shells will get hot before the rest.
As an aside, there is no evidence I've seen that lemon juice, salt or cream of tartar make any difference. This seems to be a carry-over from the idea that the cook is making a meringue, but a macaron batter is such a long way from being an intact meringue that the "stablise the egg whites" idea is probably irrelevant. I might be wrong, but I haven't seen any evidence for its value.
Thank you for the answers Duncan. I guess my problem is (3).. my oven sucks! Unfortunately i can't do anything about that, I am stuck with it for now. Again, thank you
Marina, if you think the problem is (3) then the problem could well be the tray, especially if it's a steel tray. Find yourself a thick aluminium tray and see if you still have the lopsidedness.
I came across your site today [vollisch zuffaelig] @ 35 degr. C in Manila and it matched the heat I experienced reading on French macaroons. Your "treatise" on marons alone [La Macaronicite 1 to 5 is so thorough & written in a user-friendly manner that it gives me gaense Haut.] If everybody would only see to it that he would know what you know in his own chosen field of specialty there would have been more love and harmony in this world and less strife, anger, and envy. Even late in the day, I would love to at least approximate your passion for your chosen discipline/career/profession. Man merkst es, fuellst es wie sie denken, schreiben and selbstverstaendlich, auch sprechen.
Am awed. You are absolutely a model to look up to… and I was just trifling with my fascination for marons. Now I shall aim to make some myself even if I only half-succeeded in my first try at a "Dresdner Stollen". Thank you so much for awakening that culinary zeal in me.
Alles Guete and bis dem absolut naechst.
Ihre
Wenceslao "Sut" Pascual
Hey Duncan,
I really enjoyed reading about macarons on your site. I hope that I will be able to cook them like you one day.
Unfortunately I didn't mix the ones in my 1st attempt well enough. Oh well, next time.
I can't believe it is so hard to find a decent macaron there)-:. In Japan, it's reasonably easy to find them, especially in the big department stores. Ever tried they starbucks ones? They look like an abomination!
I'd like to try and make mandarin flavored ones.
I just had my first go at making these little beauties. First batch was a flop. Second batch I added a little more almond meal to mix, left to harden up on bench a bit longer and they puffed up a treat. Only problem was that they stuck to the baking paper when I took them out of the oven. However, I simply gently lifted an edge off the paper and slid a palette knife underneath and the whole lot popped up! Great macaron guide you have here, well done! Very inspiring!
Thank you, first, for what to do with a failed attempt, coz I only got here after failing. I have a box of silly looking macarons, ate the rest which were DELICIOUS goodness!! Thank you for this wonderful post. Have to thank Manggy for sending me here. I enjoyed reading the post A LOT and was strangely sad when it finished! I think I'm building a macaron obsession, with 2 failed attempts under my belt. I'm off to investigate the Italian meringue method now. (Have checked my spellings to make sure there isn't an extra 'o')
Dear Duncan
Its very educational reading your site.. I'm often in a dillema on what cream to sandwich the macarons. Chocolate ganache is ok, but I would like to try other flavored fillings. Do you have one recipe which gives stable filling, one which won't melt in 20 mins after taking it out of the fridge? Its very humid here in Singapore..
Thanks so much/Angela
@angela: I would think that a stiffer ganache is probably your best option in those conditions. (And remember that white choc ganache is a very versatile base for many flavours.) To stiffen some fillings, try adding some finely ground almond meal.
Oh my word…I just had an absolute macaron disaster! Let me preface this by saying I live in Denver; I was nervous about trying my hand at macarons because of the elevation, but I was eager to make use of a 2 lb bag of almonds I bought recently. Macarons seemed like a fun challenge!
So, I decided to start with the Italian meringue method. Well, I had trouble getting the sugar syrup to the right consistency. I tried twice, and each time it was very clumpy and grainy. Not wanting to give up, and still having lots of ground almonds to play with, I switched gears to the French meringue method.
To be safe, I added 1/4 tsp cream of tartar to the fluffed up egg whites before adding the sugar. This seemed to work great because the meringue looked nice and glossy. Problem: I accidentally only used 25g of egg whites here because I was still in the Italian meringue mindset. Oops! But rather than start over again, I added the other 25g whites to the almond meal/sugar and plopped the meringue on top. I combined everything in about 25 strokes, but it seemed a touch too thick, so I gave it 5 more. Upon piping my rounds, the consistency seemed just right because the rounds settled nicely and didn't spread.
I let them rest for 30 minutes before turning my oven to 360 F. Popped em in, did some dishes, checked at 5 minutes and…Oh no!! Explosion!
I admit, I thought it was more hilarious than anything
) Yikes, what on earth happened?? Was it the cream of tartar? Not fluffing the eggs all at once? Oven too hot? Altitude?
I'll try again tomorrow and let you know what happens, but hopefully you can provide some insight on this mess
)
@katie: your macarons didn't work because, as you said, you made them wrongly: the French meringue method won't work if you haven't made the meringue correctly. And the cream of tartar is probably superfluous.
Ah, I feel silly now…Hopefully my next attempt will turn out ok.
I made my second batch following your instructions to the letter, but the feet still spread slightly (albeit not nearly as bad as yesterday). The feet also collapsed, leaving a huge hole in the center.
Needless to say, after 4 failures I will not be trying macarons again
(
I've visited numerous websites/blogs relating to anything macarons for awhile now but never had the guts to dive in and just try making them… until now. I'm sad to report that it turned out to be an utter disappointment (although catastrophic kept popping into mind). I knew the minute I mixed the dry ingredients with my perfectly beaten egg whites that I was destined for macawrong city (thanks for coining the word, btw). I should just come to terms with the fact that macarons are every bit as complicated and persnickety as you and other macaron masters everywhere make them out to be. I am a fool for thinking that if bbcgoodfood website has the recipe then it can't be that hard. Well, I've learned my lesson and it costed me 2 eggwhites, 140g of ground almonds and 250g of icing sugar + 2 insulated pans, a hand mixer and a basic piping set. I'll try your method next time. I'll have my hubby eat my sickly sweet macawhats. I thought I'd get that off my chest. Love your site, btw.
Thank you so much for going into so much detail with heaps of useful tips. I have attempted macarons twice. The first time I overfolded so ended up with flat, sticky soft almond meringues. Round 2 was better but still no feet and the shells had few holes and some fissures even though I tried very hard not to overfold. I am going to try round 3 today and use your recipe and all your suggestions. Thanks heaps
Duncan, thank you for an excellent teach in on macarons. This is the best treatise on making them on the internet. Thought you'd enjoy this funny blog about attempting to conquer the Everest of Macarons, those by Pierre Herme': http://www.parisperfect.com/blog/2009/10/making-the-best-macarons-in-the-world/
Will include your recipe and information on the followup blog, Macarons Recipe for Mere Mortals
[...] recipes proven to be more successful: Tarlette's recipe – a much straight forward and simple recipe Syrup and Tang – a recipe that involves three Daring Bakers to change the lightbulb Melanger – a more stable [...]
Ducan,
Thank you for taking the time to write such a wonderful blog about making French Macarons. I followed your directions exactly. I used the Italian meringue method. My macarons do have feet but some of them came out lopsided. They are all on the same tray, and therefore have been treated the same. I don't understand why they are not all perfect, or not all lopsided. I baked them at 280F for 18 mins. There are no problems with the texture, etc. The only problem is that some are lopsided. Please help.
Hi Duncan, i've been looking through some macarons articles, but yours give me clues on what errors might happens and why. I'm just a housewife with ordinary tools: conventional oven, handmixer, blender. I hope i can try with not so-many-times errors (even a great bakers can't make it perfect for the 1st time, right?)….but end up with great expectation! Thanks and wish me luck!